Mystical Palimpsest by Manjima Misra: A Literary Labyrinth of Reality and Imagination

Book Review of Mystical Palimpsest by Manjima Misra

There are books that tell stories, and then there are books that dissolve the boundaries between reality and fiction, forcing you to question the nature of perception itself. Manjima Misra’s Mystical Palimpsest: A Collection of Two Novellas is a work of the latter kind—a book that doesn’t just ask to be read but rather compels you to experience it. The very title, Mystical Palimpsest, hints at layers of hidden meanings as if the words on the page are mere shadows of deeper truths lurking beneath.

This collection of two novellas—The Ocean is Her Title and Detectives of Autumn House—is a rare literary feat, one that blends magical realism, existential introspection, and postmodern detective fiction into a tapestry of language so rich and evocative that I found myself reading passages aloud, just to hear the cadence of the words take flight.

The Ocean is Her Title: A Journey into the Abyss of the Mind

I am still looking at the vast expanse of deep blue ocean, however, there is a separation now between me and my truth.

To call The Ocean is Her Title an ordinary novella would be a disservice to its breathtaking complexity. It is, at its heart, a psychological voyage, a meditation on mental illness, storytelling, and the fragility of the human psyche. The protagonist, Poulomi, is a writer whose letters to an enigmatic figure named Jay read like an open wound—raw, poetic, and disorienting. But as her letters unravel, so does the certainty of Jay’s existence. Is he a real person? A figment of Poulomi’s imagination? A literary device of her own making?

Misra crafts a world where Poulomi is not merely lost in her thoughts but physically displaced—transported to an oceanic realm governed by Krish and Trisha, rulers who seek to understand her affliction. Here, the ocean itself becomes a metaphor for Poulomi’s internal struggle, a place where reality bends and identity dissolves. As she transforms—into waves, into a rhinoceros, into a whisper lost in the abyss—her father, Mr Chatterjee, embarks on a desperate quest to bring her back, navigating her diary entries like clues in an unsolvable riddle.

At its core, the novella is a haunting exploration of perception. Poulomi’s fixation with colour—especially the shades of greenish-blue—becomes a symbol of her shifting realities. There is an eerie beauty to her descent, an almost lyrical madness that reminds me of Kafka’s Metamorphosis, where the absurd becomes more truthful than reality itself.

It is impossible to separate Poulomi from her words, just as it is impossible to separate the artist from their art. Her letters to Jay range from tender longing to paranoid despair, reflecting the cyclical nature of her mental illness. And perhaps that is where Misra’s genius truly lies—in crafting a narrative that mirrors the mind’s own spirals, where coherence and incoherence dance like waves under an ever-changing moon.

Detectives of Autumn House: A Mystery That Refuses to Be Solved

Autumn House creates a story that urges readers to resolve a puzzle game as they walk through the wet pavements glistening with autumn leaves in the cities of London and Connaught Place.

If The Ocean is Her Title is an introspective journey, Detectives of Autumn House is an outward gaze—a detective story that is as much about crime as it is about identity, politics, and the shifting landscapes of human relationships. It reinvents the detective genre, offering not a linear whodunit but an intricate puzzle where the pieces keep changing shape.

The titular detective agency is run by an all-women team, a narrative decision that is both subversive and necessary in a genre historically dominated by men. But these women are not just crime-solvers; they are navigators of ethical dilemmas, unravelling the threads of justice in a world that often operates without it. The story moves between London and Connaught Place, crafting a vivid portrait of two cities that serve as metaphors for the modern world—fast-paced, alienating, yet brimming with secrets waiting to be unearthed.

Unlike traditional detective fiction, where the thrill lies in resolution, Detectives of Autumn House thrives in ambiguity. The multiple storylines, the ethical debates, and the exploration of queer rights and civil liberties—all of these elements make the novella feel alive as if the mystery extends beyond the pages into the reader’s own consciousness. And isn’t that the mark of true literature? That it refuses to be contained within its own story, spilling over into our thoughts long after the final page is turned?

The Language of the Sublime

We checked the college records. There is no Jay that matches the description. In fact, there was no student named Jay during her entire three years of college education.

Misra’s writing is a revelation. She has an uncanny ability to make prose feel like poetry, to craft sentences that are both delicate and devastating. Her use of repetition, colour symbolism, and philosophical musings transforms the reading experience into something almost hypnotic.

Her characters are not just people; they are vessels of thought, mirrors reflecting the reader’s own existential dilemmas. The themes of autonomy, storytelling, sanity, and justice are not merely explored but dissected, laid bare in a way that demands engagement. And yet, there is a quiet intimacy to it all, a sense that we are being allowed into the most sacred corners of these characters’ minds.

Final Thoughts: A Book That Refuses to Leave You

There is an even greater resource than time, money, and knowledge. Health—mental, emotional, and physical—gives us the ultimate personal liberty.

Mystical Palimpsest is not a book to be read; it is a book to be lived with, a book that lingers like a dream half-remembered. It challenges conventional storytelling, blurs the line between the known and the unknown, and ultimately asks us—what is real? And perhaps more importantly, does it even matter?

It is rare to find a work that is at once deeply literary and deeply human, a book that feels like both an intellectual exercise and an emotional reckoning. Manjima Misra has not merely written two novellas—she has crafted a labyrinth, inviting us to lose ourselves within its pages. And I, for one, have never been happier to be lost.

If you are a reader who craves literature that is not just a mirror but a portal, if you revel in prose that shimmers with thought and language that breathes like a living entity, then Mystical Palimpsest will enthral you. It is not an easy book, nor should it be. But it is, without a doubt, a necessary one.

Recommended for: Lovers of literary fiction, magical realism, and experimental storytelling.

Stay tuned with us right here at Booxoul for the best in the fields of entertainment, fun, finance, mental health, fashion, education, travel, tech, and gadgets, as well as all things bookish.